WASHINGTON (By Brian Stelter, NYT)
October 24, 2009
―
Instead of being simply a draw for
Hispanic viewers, CNN’s four-hour
documentary, “Hispanic in America,”
turned into a political rallying cry for
activist groups who are calling on the
cable news channel to fire Lou Dobbs, a
veteran anchor with well-known views on
immigration.
An array of minorities held small
protests in New York and other cities on
Wednesday, the first night of CNN’s
presentation.
They are trying to
highlight what they say are years of
lies about immigration by Mr. Dobbs, who
anchors the 7 p.m. hour on CNN.
CNN, a unit of Time Warner, has not
commented on the protests or covered
them on its news programs. One of the
activists featured in the documentary
said she tried to raise what she called
Mr. Dobbs’s “hatred” on one of the
channel’s news programs Wednesday, but
her remarks were cut from the interview.
The anti-Dobbs campaign has, however,
drawn considerable attention in the
Spanish-language press; the Thursday
front page of the New York newspaper El
Diario featured a red slash mark through
Mr. Dobbs’s face and the word “hipocresia,”
Spanish for “hypocrisy,” atop the
illustration.
The hypocrisy, critics say, lies in
CNN’s decision to woo Hispanic viewers
with a prime-time documentary while
still giving Mr. Dobbs a nightly forum.
Roberto Lovato, a founding member of
Presente.org, a Hispanic advocacy group,
said in a statement, “We won’t allow the
network to court us as viewers while, at
the same time, they allow Dobbs to
spread lies and misinformation about us
each night.”
Separately, Mr. Dobbs is also the target
of a “Drop Dobbs” campaign by the
progressive groups NDN, Media Matters
for America, and others. That effort
started after Mr. Dobbs repeatedly
raised questions about President Obama’s
birth certificate.
There is no indication the campaigns are
affecting CNN’s revenue, but they are
highlighting Mr. Dobbs’s status as an
outlier at the channel, which has sought
to position itself as a middle ground of
sorts in the fractious cable news arena.
Mr. Dobbs is known to be exploring an
exit from CNN, and he is viewed as a
potential hire for the Fox Business
Network, an upstart channel owned by the
News Corporation.
The Hispanic campaign’s Web site,
BastaDobbs.com, features a video
compilation of past comments by the CNN
anchor, including his claim in October
2006 that “about a third of the prison
population in this country is estimated
to be illegal aliens.” He was apparently
referring to federal prisoners, and he
later acknowledged the claim was made
multiple times in error.
As the timing of the prison comment
indicates, there is nothing new about
Mr. Dobbs’s controversial stance toward
immigration, and CNN executives have
argued his hour long evening program
hews more closely to a newscast.
Privately, when some executives are
asked about the Dobbs complaints, they
sometimes cite the production of
“Hispanic in America,” with the
implication being the channel presents
many points of view. The documentary,
which drew an average of about 900,000
viewers on Wednesday and Thursday,
follows two editions of “Black in
America.” It presented Hispanic
activists with a new rallying point this
fall.
Isabel Garcia, a civil rights lawyer who
was featured in “Hispanic in America”
and organized an anti-Dobbs protest in
Tucson on Wednesday, said CNN edited her
comments about the anchor out of an
interview.
She had expected a 15-minute
conversation about immigration opposite
Joe Arpaio, the sheriff of Maricopa
County, Ariz., and a staunch supporter
in immigration enforcement, on the
prime-time program “Anderson Cooper
360.” During the taped interview
Wednesday, she said she made several
unprompted comments about Mr. Dobbs.
She said she called Mr. Arpaio and Mr.
Dobbs “the two most dangerous men to our
communities,” and said “because of them,
our communities are being terrorized in
a real way.” She also asserted CNN was
“promoting lies and hate about our
community” by broadcasting Mr. Dobbs’s
program. The comments were not included
when the interview was shown Wednesday
night.
“They heavily deleted what I did get to
say,” she said.
CNN said the segment in question was
tied to “Hispanic in America.”
“As with all pre-taped interviews, they
are edited for time and relevance to the
topic of discussion,” a spokeswoman
said. “The debate between Isabel Garcia
and Joe Arpaio was no exception.”