SANTA FE, NM
(By
Julia Meena Hartenstein, Daily News)
June 15, 2010
― Reports are swirling Hispanics
in Arizona are fleeing the state
before a controversial new
immigration law goes into effect
July 29.
The law, which has sparked a heated
national debate, requires police
officers to conduct routine traffic
stops or other checks to ask people
about their immigration status if
there is "reasonable suspicion"
they're in the country illegally.
Though precise numbers are not yet
available, early anecdotal reports
from local schools, businesses and
residents indicate Hispanics could
be leaving in droves to avoid the
law's impact, USA Today reported
Wednesday.
Superintendent Jeffrey Smith of the
Balsz Elementary School District,
which is 75% Hispanic, said 70
students were pulled out of school
following the law's passage April 23
and parents said it was the reason
they were leaving.
Retailers are expecting the hit too.
David Castillo, co-founder of the
Latin Association of Arizona, told
USA Today local businesses serving
the Hispanic community have started
to report declining profits, an
indicator illegal immigrants are
stockpiling their cash to prepare
for a move.
This isn't the first time an Arizona
law has prompted a population shift.
About 100,000 illegal immigrants
moved elsewhere after a law was
passed in 2007 that penalized
businesses for hiring them,
according to the Department of
Homeland Security.
A recent Census report also suggests
Hispanics have been leaving Arizona
since the recession began -
approximately 40,000 relocated in
2008. Those who move typically do
not return to Mexico but re-settle
in other, friendlier states.
Paul Senseman, a spokesman for
Republican Governor Jan Brewer who
signed the inflammatory law, said he
had heard similar reports of
Hispanics planning to flee. "If that
means that fewer people are breaking
the law, that is absolutely an
accomplishment," he told USA Today.
In all likelihood, Arizona will not
see "tangible evidence" of any
population change until late in the
year when the schools are required
to report their enrollment numbers,
Amy Rezzonico, spokeswoman for the
Arizona Department of Education,
told Fox News.
David Gutierrez, an immigration
history professor at the University
of California San Diego, said he is
hesitant to predict the law will
have a dramatic impact on the
numbers of Arizona Hispanics.
Gutierrez told the Christian Science
Monitor, I dont see a historical
trend that has been in place for 100
years will be reversed because
youve got a few hyper-conservative
white legislators trying to turn
back the clock, turn back the tides
of history.
That being said, Gutierrez believes
a mass exodus would be crippling for
the state. "If I were able to
conduct an experiment and pay all of
Arizonas undocumented workers to
not work for two weeks, the economy
would come to a screeching, crashing
halt instantaneously.
The clash over immigration continues
to rage across the country.
The Arizona SB 1070 Cancer begins
to spread to 18 states
Today in Chicago, NBC reports,
Alderman Danny Solis compared
Arizona's law to Hitler's Third
Reich. "In the early stages of Nazi
Germany, there was a law that
identified particular groups of
people," Solis said. "This law has
identified a particular group of
people.
Solis added, "This law is evil."